Letter: Sierra Club has strayed from its mission with Apex

Letter: Sierra Club has strayed from its mission with Apex

  • 0

Recently the Sierra Club of Western New York endorsed the proposed Apex industrial wind turbine project in Niagara and Orleans counties.

This endorsement came despite the findings of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the American Bird Conservancy that concluded these structures would result in the massive killing of birds, including bald eagles. The ABC has gone so far as to list this project as one of the 10 worst sited projects in the nation for killing birds.

How could the Sierra Club, an organization founded on the preservation and conservation of avian life, issue such an endorsement?

The reason given by the Sierra Club essentially was that because climate change will result in the extinction of all animal life on the planet, it may be necessary to tolerate the killing of birds now, in order to save the species later.

As a U.S. Army veteran serving in Germany during the Vietnam War era, I recall hearing of a most infamous event.

In February 1968, an American patrol along with heavy artillery and air strikes completely destroyed the village of Ben Tre. At a briefing that included journalists, a U.S. military officer explained the action by saying “It became necessary to destroy the town to save it.”

This quote is still used today to illustrate absurd logic that can lead to absurd and failed strategies.

It seems the Sierra Club, in abandoning its founding principles, has adopted the same absurd logic.

There is obviously political motivation behind this to downplay any and all documented side effects of industrial wind turbines.

Maybe the Sierra Club’s new slogan should be: “It became necessary to annihilate western New York’s avian population in order to save them.”

Robert LaPorte

Barker

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

On May 23, Jo Jorgensen entered the 2020 election race as a Libertarian, opposing both President Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden. Just over half of all eligible voters cast their ballots in 2016, often considered “the most important election of our lifetime.” Why are half of Americans abandoning our political system? When two parties are so similar,

With tens of thousands of protesters and rioters out in public in without face masks, if there in no surge in coronavirus cases in two weeks, I will no longer be wearing a mask as this will prove this “emergency” was all a social experiment and giant overreach by our government. Richard Pearce

With racial injustice making the headlines once again and hearing the term “white privilege” I have been thinking deeply about what that term means. I’ve thought, “I don’t think I’m privileged,” I grew up poor on the East Side of Buffalo. My mother became disabled when I was one year old. My father was a taxi driver when he

In about four months we’ll be voting in a presidential election and millions of citizens will cast their vote based solely, and in many cases blindly, on their candidate, not knowing or caring about what that person has accomplished in the past or will accomplish for the next four years. What they should consider is that for decades, corporations

With tens of thousands of protesters and rioters out in public in without face masks, if there in no surge in coronavirus cases in two weeks, I will no longer be wearing a mask as this will prove this “emergency” was all a social experiment and giant overreach by our government. Richard Pearce

When my teenage grandson and friends peacefully marched from Niagara Square to Bidwell Parkway, I have never been prouder, or more hopeful for change. For so many generations, we discussed, protested and legislated to end racial based murders, injustice, discrimination and the senseless mass shootings. Coverage of the ongoing protests has highlighted, very little has changed for people of

Colin Kaepernick knelt during the National Anthem to raise awareness of the oppression of black and people of color in the United States of America. Being present on the field and taking a knee was an extremely brave, poignant and very American act of peaceful and respectful protest. In the aftermath of the graphic documentation of George Floyd’s murder

Much appreciation to Buffalo News writer Scott Scanlon for the excellent article on health clubs and gyms reopening. It is important for people to stay in shape, both physically and mentally. In my case, due to various sports and military injuries the only way I can do aerobics is using the machines at my gym. In three months, I’ve

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

News Alerts

Breaking News