Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
A question of legacy: Gary Numan fights music biz ageism

A question of legacy: Gary Numan fights music biz ageism

  • 0
Support this work for $1 a month

Electronic rock pioneer Gary Numan plays the Town Ballroom on Dec. 2. (Getty Images)

Your legacy.

If you're a musician who has been around for decades, what you'll leave behind in terms of influence becomes an increasingly paramount concern. You'd like to know that your work meant something to subsequent generations of listeners and musicians. And if it did, you'd like credit for it. Unfortunately, the music business is not necessarily your ally in this regard.

Gary Numan's just-released album "Savage (Songs from a Broken World)" –  an album that is comprised almost exclusively of electronic instrumentation – has been deemed by Billboard "not electronic enough" to qualify for the trade journal's electronic music chart, where it quite likely would've debuted in the top slot last week. Instead, Numan has been banished to the alternative music charts, where the competition is much more diverse and the likelihood of getting lost in the shuffle much greater. Go figure.

Numan, who plays the Town Ballroom on Dec. 2, is clearly one of the progenitors of electronic music. His late-'70s work with synthesizers, which owes a debt to the suite of electronic pieces on side 2 of David Bowie's 1977 masterwork "Low," helped to launch the synth-pop movement that would yield results both glorious and horrifying in the '80s. He pushed synths forward in the mix, created a soundscape bereft of the electric guitars that had long dominated rock music, and infiltrated the mainstream. It's hard to imagine what '80s music might have sounded like without the ominous  synth snarl and eerily robotic rhythm of "Cars," and its ubiquitous music video, wherein Numan comes across as an icy cool, pasty, detached and aloof robot.


"Savage" lives up to its title and then some, and rather handily displays the obvious influence Numan's work has had on everyone from Prince to Nine Inch Nails and the Wu Tang Clan's RZA, to say nothing of Depeche Mode, Thomas Dolby and the like. It is the work of a still-vibrant artist.

The issue with Billboard speaks to a number of things, among them just how absurd is the need for those in the sales business to compartmentalize music solely by marketing-based niche. At the heart of the problem is the issue of legacy, however. For Numan, this is a question of getting his due as a deeply influential electronic musician amidst an atmosphere of blatant ageism.

That ageism accepts as implicit the need for artists of a certain vintage to get out of the way for younger, prettier, more marketable ones. Hit the casino circuit or the nostalgia package-tour route, fine. But don’t expect to be treated as an artist in the present tense. Just go out there and play your old hit, cash the check and be on your way.

Such an ethos makes sense to marketing types, but it is of course anathema to musicians. Numan –  a self-taught player who did groundbreaking work in electronic music almost by accident, having stumbled upon a Moog synth in a recording studio and mucked about with it until he found some sounds that pleased him – is loyal to the idea of experimentation in the present tense. That experimental streak informed Numan's decision to forego major record labels several decades back. Unsurprisingly, he is no lover of streaming sites and their attendant royalty models, either. "You could not possibly earn a living, unless you’re Rihanna," he told For Numan, the current music business climate represents "the savage throws of a dying monster and the sooner it’s gone, the better."

One suspects that Numan's work will endure well past that point. Prince certainly seemed to think so. "Do you like Gary Numan?" he asks author Jake Brown in the book "Prince in the Studio." "You know, his (1979) album 'Replicas' never left my turntable … There are people still trying to work out what a genius he was."

Apparently, some of those people work for Billboard.




Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

  • Updated

What a seismic difference a trial has made to public and media perceptions of Kyle Rittenhouse. When he was charged at age 17 with shooting three men, two fatally, during racial unrest in Kenosha, Wisconsin, last year, various media accounts described him as a rifle-toting white supremacist who drove across the border to shoot Black Lives Matters protesters in the racial unrest that followed ...

  • Updated

What can sensible adults agree on regarding Kyle Rittenhouse, the latest young symbol on whom America can hang its devastating internal division and the newest tool for social media networks to monetize without regard to individual and societal hurt? Those who believe in the rule of law, which should be all of us, might start with the notion that a murder trial involving self-defense is no ...

  • Updated

Kyle Rittenhouse is 18 years old. On Aug. 25, 2020, when Rittenhouse killed two men during a night of civil unrest in Kenosha, Wisconsin, he was 17. But when he took the stand during his murder trial, he looked like he could be 13. Defendants in murder trials often do themselves no favors by testifying in their own defense, but Rittenhouse probably helped himself. He was soft-spoken and ...

  • Updated

Since 1984, the nationwide legal drinking age has been 21 for good reasons. Young people’s brains are still developing, which affects their judgment and cognitive abilities. That, along with raging hormones, boosts the chances of impulsive decision-making. It’s a dumb idea to add alcohol to an already unstable mix. It makes even less sense to add firearms to that unstable mix. Perhaps it’s ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News