Say Cheese! Pizza Company at 1771 Love Rd #1 on Grand Island is a unique restaurant with a comic book theme. It has a comic book store, and many other collectibles including life-size superheroes statues, all which are for sale. Bartender Lisa Adame talks with John McGinty, center, and Dave Zimmerman, of Grand Island. The bar top is decorated with comic book covers. Photo taken, Tuesday, July 31, 2018. (Sharon Cantillon/Buffalo News)
Say Cheese! Pizza Company at 1771 Love Rd #1 on Grand Island is a unique restaurant with a comic book theme. It has a comic book store, and many other collectibles including life-size superheroes statues, all which are for sale. A large Spider Man starue sits above the entrance. Photo taken, Tuesday, July 31, 2018. (Sharon Cantillon/Buffalo News)
Say Cheese! Pizza Company at 1771 Love Rd #1 on Grand Island is a unique restaurant with a comic book theme. It has a comic book store, and many other collectibles including life-size superheroes statues, all which are for sale. This is their Dorito burrito with tater tots. Photo taken, Tuesday, July 31, 2018. (Sharon Cantillon/Buffalo News)
The full name of the establishment located at 1771 Love Road in Grand Island is Say Cheese Pizza Co./The Comic Book Cafe, but it’s the latter moniker that’s remembered. Ask local superhero aficionados about Say Cheese Pizza Co., and you’ll get a shoulder shrug. Ask about the Comic Book Cafe, and you’ll get a high-five.
That is not because of the food, although the food is fine. What makes the Comic Book Cafe so beloved is the scenery -- inside and out.
When you drive up, you’ll spot Spider-Man on the roof, as well as a wall of comic art. Enter, and you are greeted with life-size statues of nearly every Marvel and DC comics character worth noting: Thor, Hulk, Superman, Batman, the Flash.
Comics are, quite literally, everywhere. While there are the usual accouterments of a restaurant and bar, there is no escaping the masked-hero theme.
Best of all, in the eyes of my 8-year-old, was the presence of a comic book shop featuring toys, memorabilia and comics. It’s an interesting mix of Marvel and DC fare, as well as "Star Wars" and a few others.
During our visit on a weekday afternoon, we were seated at a booth directly across from said shop, and that was a good thing. It certainly made for easy browsing.
We were brought to our seat with a regular menu for me, and a kids menu (and some crayons) for my son. All of the kids items were less than $10, and while it was the usual suspects, his choice was clear: two slices of pizza and a drink.
I was in dire need of hot sauce, so I ordered chicken fingers and fries ($12 for five, $19 for 10). Were it not 11:15 a.m. on a Wednesday, I would have gone with a beer -- and I would have been very satisfied with my options. The Comic Book Cafe beer list is tremendous -- I quickly noted the presence of some my local favorites on draft, like Resurgence and Hamburg Brewing Company -- and the prices are not bad.
Domestic and Canadian beers hover around $4.50 or $6.50 depending on size, while craft brews are $6 or $8. (The entire beer list can be found on the restaurant’s Facebook page.)
While our food choices were highly unadventurous, there are some (slightly) more unique picks available. A friend, who finds the Cafe to be perfect for “alleged grownups” like himself, highly recommends the Old World-Style Pizza (featuring imported olive oil, old-world pepperoni, and lots of oregano and garlic).
These gourmet pizzas are a bit more expensive than the normal pies -- $15.99 for a medium, $22.99 for a large, $26.99 for a two-foot pie, and $35.99 for party-size. I made a mental note to try the Classic Chicago (deep-dish style) and stuffed banana pepper pizzas in the future.
If you are uninterested in the gourmet styles, there are plenty of pizza and wing specials, starting at $20.99 for a medium pie and ten wings. Also noteworthy are a number of lunch specials under $10, including two slices of cheese and pepperoni and a drink for $6.49.
There is, in fact, plenty on the menu for less than $10, including most of the appetizers, many of the hoagies, and some smaller salads.
What truly made my son’s day, however, had nothing to do with food. It was a very clever kids menu toy add-on: With the purchase of a kids meal and an additional $4, kiddos can get a random mini figure toy. It is worth noting that these are not official Lego products.
My son received a figure clearly modeled after the Flash, but with a shield that read “THE FSALH.” Hey, close enough. It was a nice treat, and kept us from coveting a more expensive item in the comic shop.
With inspired design, plenty of inexpensive options, and some neat surprises, the conveniently located Say Cheese Pizza Co./The Comic Book Cafe is a winner. I’d like to think the Flash, and the Fsalh, would both leave satisfied.
CHEAP EATS
Say Cheese Pizza Co./The Comic Book Cafe
1771 Love Road, Grand Island (775-0333)
Hours: 11 a.m. to midnight daily
Parking: Lot.
Wheelchair accessible: Yes.
Gluten-free and dairy-free options: A veggie pizza and a number of salads are available.