Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.

A compelling, charming cast shines in compelling 'Magnolia Ballet'

  • Updated
  • 0
Alleyway Theatre Magnolia Ballet

Richard Satterwhite and  Nigel Reynolds play father and son in "Magnolia Ballet" at Alleyway Theatre.

Support this work for $1 a month

In his program notes for “Magnolia Ballet,” director Carlos Jones reminds us that certain types of stories seldom find their way to the stage in the American theater. He’s talking specifically about the “Black/queer male coming-of-age story” of the very sort that playwright Terry Guest tells in “Magnolia Ballet,” which opened this week at Alleyway Theatre.

Guest’s play is getting a good deal of exposure, thanks to the National New Play Network “Rolling World Premiere” program. Traditionally, a play has its world premiere at one theater, after which it is usually never seen again. Playwrights call this the “one-and-done” paradigm. Through “Rolling World Premiere,” the National New Play Network supports three or more theaters that choose to mount the same new play within a 12-month period. “Magnolia Ballet” is being produced in Buffalo, and also at theaters in Indiana and Michigan.

It will be difficult for any production to compete with the sheer charm of the Buffalo cast. Young Nigel Reynolds, a recent SUNY Fredonia graduate, is adorable as Ezekiel Mitchell, a 17-year-old African American kid living with his father in rural Georgia. Reynolds projects a combination of youthful innocence and joyful goodness, while at the same time, a world of worry weighs down on him.

His father, determined to prepare him for an unfair world, is hard on Ezekiel. On top of that, the boy is holding a secret. He is gay.

Reynolds creates a character who, despite the ways that life knocks him down, always bounces back up with a resiliency that is, at times, heartbreaking. We yearn for this young man’s happiness.

The story is told in a non-realistic style, with doubling of characters, expressionistic sequences, and even a ghost. Sydney Lynne, a Chicago-based installation and scenic designer has designed the set, which suggests the Mitchell’s humble home and its adjacent shed. Janessa A. Harris, a Houston-based lighting designer, has created the heavily textured lighting. Zech Saenz from Indiana has done the costumes, and Willow James has designed the sound. They create a world that fluctuates between past and present, reality and dreams, as this story unfolds.

Magnolia Ballet Alleyway Theatre

Nigel Reynolds, left, and Shawn Adiletta give winning performances in "Magnolia Ballet" presented by Alleyway Theatre.

Ezekiel is feeling the surge of first love with his friend, Danny, who is white, and whose last name is also Mitchell. This relationship is a source of both anxiety and joy, however, for the boys’ fathers grew up together, and Ezekiel’s father is harsh and to make matters worse, he harbors animosity towards Danny’s father for his deep racism.

Richard Satterwhite plays both fathers, imbuing one with smoldering gravitas and the other with comic buffoonery. His entrance as Danny’s father, a redneck sheriff, is one of the evening’s comic highlights, and Guest is, perhaps, strongest as a playwright when he makes his boldest theatrical gestures.

Shawn Adiletta gives a winning performance as conflicted Danny Mitchell, a boy with a cheerful and sarcastic manner, who yearns to escape the darker aspects of his family and regional heritage.

Dennis Wilson plays the apparition of Ezekiel’s grandfather, and in one marvelous scene, the ghost of his mother. This scene ignites the audience with the character’s first, “Well, well, well!” as Wilson demonstrates his grace and versatility as an actor.

There is a lot packed into the play, which its fluid structure is able to sustain. The momentum of the plot is divided into discrete sequences. The language is dense and highly poetic. At times the script bursts into kind of spoken arias, as characters speak their truth with dense and heightened language. Contrasts are introduced easily, as in the casting of one actor as both fathers, or when the two boys collaborate on a class project about the Civil War and find themselves at cross purposes.

There is perhaps one coincidence too many, occurring when Ezekiel and Danny’s fathers turn out to have harbored identical secrets, both documented identically through preserved stashes of letters. While there might have been many avenues to conclude the play, Guest lights on a most melodramatic finish.

Still, the play is consistently engaging and its themes are explored in highly absorbing fashion. The cast is uniformly compelling and the direction is taut and elegant. Alleyway has given this moving play a very handsome premiere.

Theater review


4 stars (out of 4)

Presented by Alleyway Theatre at 1 Curtain Up Alley through Oct. 2. Performances are 7:30 p.m. Sept. 22-24, 28-30 and Oct. 1; 3:30 p.m. Sept. 24 and 2 p.m. Oct. 2.Industry night is Sept. 27. Tickets are $42 general, $30 for 30 and younger (, 716-852-2600).

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News