Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Benderson proceeds with reuse of former Bon-Ton in Tonawanda; Northtown seeks more parking

Benderson proceeds with reuse of former Bon-Ton in Tonawanda; Northtown seeks more parking

Support this work for $1 a month
Bon Ton Tonawanda Rendering

A rendering of the renovated former Bon-Ton store in Tonawanda. 

Benderson Development Co. is moving ahead with its conversion of the two-story former Bon-Ton Department Store in Tonawanda into medical and office space, after receiving approval from the town last week for minor changes to an outparcel building.

The Florida-based developer, which owns the Sheridan-Delaware Plaza at 1692-1752 Sheridan Drive, is transforming the vacant 93,861-square-foot store building into 62,782 square feet of medical offices, plus additional retail spaces. Work began in late 2019, although it was paused briefly during the pandemic.

Bon Ton Store Tonawanda

The former Bon-Ton store at 1692 Sheridan Drive, Tonawanda, shown shortly after its 2018 closing. Owner Benderson Development Co. wants to convert the first floor to medical offices. 

The firm has not yet identified any tenants for the medical space, but has Northwest Savings Bank at one end and Great Clips tucked in the middle, with two spaces of 5,528 square feet and 616 square feet still available.

Benderson separately already demolished the 30,454-square-foot Bon-Ton Home Store that was also part of the retail center. That is being replaced with an 8,500-square-foot outbuilding facing Delaware Avenue, with a drive-thru.

Sheridan-Delaware outparcel

The planned outparcel building at the Sheridan-Delaware Plaza.

The developer has signed leases with Starbucks and Rachel's Mediterranean for the two ends of that new building, but there's still 4,000 square feet of space remaining in the middle.

The plaza, one of the area's oldest open-air shopping centers, has been owned by Benderson since 1997. It's anchored by a 56,899-square-foot Tops Markets grocery. The Bon-Ton, which was formerly an AM&A's store, closed in 2018 following the chain's bankruptcy.

Meanwhile, Northtown Automotive Companies – whose continued expansion means it needs more space to park cars – received approval and a special-use permit from the town to use the former Roadhouse Grill property at 1980 Niagara Falls Blvd. for automobile storage.

The dealership group, which will lease the property until it completes a purchase, will use 150 existing parking spaces, while auctioning off the restaurant equipment and using the interior space for other storage needs, according to an application to the town.

The Buffalo News: Good Morning, Buffalo

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

  • Updated

The former Bon-Ton store and Bon-Ton Home Store properties in the Sheridan Delaware Plaza could see new life under plans submitted to the Town of Tonawanda by Benderson Development Co. The buildings are located at 1692-1752 Sheridan Drive, at Delaware Avenue, in the plaza anchored by Tops Markets. The developer would tear down the 30,454-square-foot Bon-Ton Home Store and

  • Updated

A company developing a vacant building in Cheektowaga got asked a lot of questions about all the vacant “spec” buildings in town Monday night. Benderson Development Co. presented plans for the redevelopment of the old Brand Names store at 3385 Union Road near Walden Avenue into South Union Square, a retail plaza. The company is seeking a rezoning from

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News