Share this article

print logo

Seven-course Buffalo craft beer menu for Thanksgiving Day

Your beer lineup for this year’s Thanksgiving is perhaps more important than usual since it's also game day for the Buffalo Bills who will square off against the Dallas Cowboys (4:30 p.m. on CBS). If you haven’t already been thinking about what beers to enjoy with your turkey, stuffing and pumpkin pie, I can be of some assistance.

This year, think of Thanksgiving as a marathon, not a sprint. You need the right beer to drink before the Bills take the field and during the game, the right beer to pair with Thanksgiving dinner and dessert, and then everything that comes afterward.

This list will help you craft the perfect Thanksgiving beer list to accompany your turkey day from first course to final bite.

Pills Mafia from Thin Man Brewery will work well as a pregame Thanksgiving Day beer.

Before the game

Pills Mafia Pilsner, Thin Man Brewery
492 Elmwood Ave. (923-4100), 166 Chandler St. (393-4355), 4401 Transit Road, Clarence (633-9630)

There’s another game on before the Bills hit the gridiron, so reach for something light to pace yourself. Pills Mafia is light and crisp with just the right amount of crackery malt note, so you don’t have to feel bad having a few before game time. See also: Community Beer Works' Let's Go Pils.

During the game

Dallas Is Going Down, Gary! Buffalo-Style IPA, Resurgence Brewing Company
1250 Niagara St. (381-9868) and 55 Chicago St. (768-6018)

What is a Buffalo-style IPA you ask? Does it really matter? Fine, it’s a double dry-hopped New England IPA. The can features Bills Mafia legend Mark Miller, who memorably proclaimed the Bills were going to beat the Cowboys in Super Bowl XVII during "The George Michael Sports Machine."

There is the argument that you could enjoy these before the game and have the pilsners during. To each their own. This is a brewery-only release, so be sure to get to Resurgence for this limited-release beer.

With Thanksgiving dinner

Borderland IPA, 42 North Brewing
25 Pine St., East Aurora (805-7500)

A nice IPA with medium hop bitterness is the perfect complement to roasted turkey. If you were go with anything more aggressively hopped, it would be too overpowering. Borderland toes the line with flavors of tropical fruit, stone fruit and citrus, all of which should add to your dining experience, even if you go for the extra sized slice of cranberry.

MacBison Scotch Ale, Flying Bison Brewing
840 Seneca St. (873-1557)

If you’d like something darker to go with your big dinner, then grab Flying Bison’s MacBison Scotch Ale, which is available in crowlers for the first time this year. The rich malts and herbal hops will serve as the ultimate pairing for a fresh bird.

Big Ditch Brewing Company's Make Me Wanna Stout goes well with Thanksgiving dessert. (Sharon Cantillon/News file photo)

With dessert

Make Me Wanna Stout Milk Stout, Big Ditch Brewing
55 E Huron St. (854-5050)

You’re hopefully celebrating a big Bills win at this point, so why not crack open a Bills-themed dessert brew just in time for the pies, cookies and cakes to hit the table. Notes of rich coffee, vanilla and cream will pair perfectly with every one of those sugary concoctions you’re putting on your plate. See also: Big Ditch Chocolate Cream Porter.

Fireside Flannel S'mores Porter, Brickyard Brewing
436 Center St., Lewiston (754-7227)

Speaking of dessert beers, how does a s’mores porter sound? Pretty good, I would imagine. Fireside Flannel’s mix of graham cracker, marshmallow and chocolate is a perfect digestif, and will definitely help you sink into your couch with a piece of pie nearby.

10 Buffalo beers to help circle the wagons at your next Bills tailgate


You’ve now made it through a huge Bills game, appetizers, dinner with all of the fixings, and then dessert, so now the world is your oyster and you are free to do as you wish ... but might I make one last suggestion?

Commiseration Bourbon Barrel Aged Imperial Stout, Five & 20 Spirits & Brewing
8398 W. Main St., Westfield (793-9463)

End your night and help accelerate your eventual food coma with a bottle of Five & 20’s heavy hitter Commiseration, a 12.8% imperial stout aged in bourbon barrels. What better way to end your night than with a cornucopia of booze, oak, chocolate, caramel, dark fruit and more. I suggest sharing the bottle, but who am I to tell you what to do?

Story topics: / /

There are no comments - be the first to comment