Share this article

print logo

From beef on weck to spaghetti parm: Where to find best of Buffalo food

Buffalo is famously known for creating the chicken wing, but its other contributions to the culinary arena are worthy of the same attention.

From the unique beef on weck sandwich, which attracted the attention of late-night host Jimmy Fallon, to sponge candy's appearance on NPR, Paula's Donuts' shoutout on Buzzfeed and a widely viewed Daily Beast article praising Buffalo-style pizza, local specialties are on their way to national recognition.

Whether you're a local or an expat looking forward to your next visit home, here's where to find five of Buffalo's best specialty foods.

Beef on weck

The classic: Anderson's Frozen Custard (six locations in the Buffalo area, all listed here)

At $6.19 and $7.19 for 3-ounce and 5-ounce sandwiches, respectively, Anderson's is a no-brainer for a quick, cheap beef on weck. The eatery also features global-themed sandwiches with Greek, Italian and Midwestern influence, spicing up the Western New York staple.

[Read more: Anderson's, the ultimate comfort food]

Personal favorite: Schwabl's (789 Center Road, West Seneca)

If you're looking for an artisan-style beef on weck, Schwabl's certainly won't disappoint. Its half-pound sandwich ($9.89 to $13.99) is a deliciously juicy, fresh, hand-carved rendition – the establishment has been serving sandwiches since 1837, after all. Pair it with a side of German potato salad and you'll be good to go.

[Related: A classic - ham in clove gravy at Schwabl's]

Fowler's sponge candy made with dark chocolate. (Sharon Cantillon/News file photo)

Sponge candy 

The classic: Fowler's Chocolates (six locations, all listed here)

You can't talk sponge candy without acknowledging the creator of the treat: Fowler's Chocolates, who's been making the Buffalo staple since 1910. The styrofoamy crunch of the caramel-colored toffee slightly resembles the taste of molasses but is unlike any other candy out there. It's so good, Sept. 21 was officially recognized as National Sponge Candy Day in 2105. One-pound boxes of milk, dark and orange chocolate are $27.50.

Personal favorite: Parkside Candy (3208 Main St., 1949 Colvin Blvd., and the McKinley Mall, 3701 McKinley Parkway, Blasdell)

One of my earliest memories is walking into Parkside Candy with my grandma as a kid and splitting a box of sponge candy and ever since, it's been my go-to spot. At $11.50 for an 8-ounce box and $22.99 for a pound, Parkside offers sponge candy in milk, dark and orange chocolate. To beat the summer heat, try freezing a few pieces for a tasty frozen treat.

[Photos: Inside the Parkside Candy business]

Spaghetti parmesan 

The classic and personal favorite: Chef's (291 Seneca St.)

Dubbed "Buffalo's favorite pasta" by News food critic Andrew Galarneau, Buffalonians are crazy for spaghetti parm. Created at Chef's in the 1960s, the dish ($10.25 to $13.50) has become a right of passage for foodies looking for Buffalo's signature dish and families celebrating milestone-worthy dinners.

Peanut stick | Paula's Donuts | Buffalo Made | Buffalo Magazine

The peanut stick at Paula's Donuts is a feast in itself.

Peanut stick

The classic: DiCamillo Bakery (five locations, all listed here)

DiCamillo Bakery has been churning out tasty treats for almost a century, and the peanut stick, the bakery's most popular doughnut according to its website, has become a local staple. It's no wonder why the sticks – featuring light and fluffy dough combined with fresh peanuts coated in a honey glaze – are shipped across the nation (including this two-dozen deal).

Personal favorite: Paula's Donuts (2319 Sheridan Drive, Tonawanda; 8560 Main St., Clarence; Southgate Plaza, 936 Union Road, West Seneca)

Whenever I find myself ordering doughnut from Paula's, which is more often than I'd like to admit, I can't leave without grabbing a peanut stick. There's nothing better than a fresh one right out of the fryer, the dough melting in your mouth and the peanuts nearly turning to peanut butter as you chew. No one does it better than Paula's, whose variation is the biggest, densest peanut stick I've found.

[Related: How Paula's cannoli doughnut helped Hospice]

Chicken finger sub 

The classic: Jim's Steakout (10 locations in the Buffalo area – all listed here)

From clubgoers on Allen Street at 4 a.m. to high schoolers looking for cheap eats, the chicken finger sub has found a spot in the hearts of Buffalonians of all ages. There's something about the simple act of placing the bar fare on a sub roll and loading it up with blue cheese or hot sauce that makes it irresistible. At $10.55 for a footlong sub, Jim's hits it out of the park where chicken finger subs are concerned.

Personal favorite: Cafe 59 (62 Allen St.)

Quietly tucked away among the bars and boutique eateries on Allen Street, Cafe 59 serves the best chicken finger sub in Buffalo. The chicken fingers, generously battered and deep-fried to golden brown perfection, are absolutely massive cuts of chicken that will put any other tender to shame.

Topped with bleu cheese, hot sauce, crisp field greens and tomato, the sub ($9.95) has become a go-to comfort food I look forward to eating while visiting home.

[Read more: At Cafe 59, a low-key, modern foodie haven]

Story topics: / / / / / / / / / / / / /

There are no comments - be the first to comment