Share this article

print logo

Editorial: Dangerous indifference in Customs officers' lead exposure

Two related and disturbing facts emerge from the acrid smoke surrounding lead contamination at a local gun range. First is that officers of U.S. Customs and Border Protection and their families were put at heightened risk to their long-term health. Second is that, with even a little due diligence, it all could have been avoided.

That needs to be the lesson going forward, for Customs and police and any other public agency that needs to ensure that its members are proficient with firearms.

At the site in question, Niagara Gun Range in Wheatfield, the owners have said the contamination occurred in an area the general public did not use and that in the aftermath of the contamination’s discovery, the range has been professionally cleaned. Going forward, the range’s general manager said, periodic cleanings will occur.

That’s appropriate, but why wouldn’t such precautions have been a condition of doing business? Since it’s a matter of public health, why didn’t local government insist upon regular cleaning and public inspections?

And, perhaps most troubling, why didn’t U.S. Customs and Border Protection protect its own workers by insisting upon a verifiably safe environment in exchange for its business? Shouldn’t that have been basic due diligence?

A December inspection by a federal industrial hygienist found that the facility, where hundreds of Customs officials had trained for more than a decade, was heavily contaminated with lead, a potentially hazardous metal that was found even in the microwave oven and the coffee pot.

“Wipe samples revealed widespread lead contamination throughout the facility including surfaces used for eating, drinking and hand contact,” the report concluded. The potential for serious, lifelong health problems is plain.

In testing that followed, two officers were found to have unusually high levels of lead in their blood. They will go for additional medical testing. But that’s only the start of the worries.

Officers with young children are worried that they might have exposed their offspring to lead by going home in contaminated clothing. That’s potentially catastrophic.

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, lead poisoning can harm virtually every body system in children, including the central nervous system, kidneys and reproductive system. At high levels, it can cause coma, convulsions and death.

Even low levels of lead in young children’s blood can produce decreased intelligence, impaired neurobehavioral development, decreased stature and growth and impaired hearing, according to the CDC. And because there are frequently no obvious symptoms, lead poisoning in children can go undetected. No safe blood lead level has been identified in children.

Conditions were bad at the gun range, according to Paul Kwiatkowski, president of the union local that represents most local Customs and Border Protection employees. “You couldn’t even breathe when you were shooting your guns,” he said. “There was no filtration system whatsoever. The smoke was so thick, it was burning your eyes and choking you.”

It is incomprehensible that, in one of the country’s most over-regulated states and in a region where lead poisoning has been a chronic problem, such a level of contamination had even a chance to accumulate. This was a systemic failure: of the gun range, of U.S. Customs and Border Protection and of local public health leaders. The price of that failure is yet to be calculated but if the issues weren’t plain before, they are now

The question going forward is, what is going to be different?

There are no comments - be the first to comment