Share this article

print logo

Transcript of Bishop Malone's statement regarding abuse, calls for him to resign

This is a complete transcript of Bishop Richard J. Malone's statement Sunday afternoon concerning sexual abuse, calls for him to resign and other issues. He made the statement in the chapel of a former convent at St. Stanislaus Parish on Buffalo's East Side. 

This is my iced tea, I’m not sure the Felician nuns who lived here forever would be happy I brought it in the chapel, but here it is.

Good afternoon everybody and thank you very much for coming on short notice on a Sunday afternoon.

You are the first group to come into what is soon to be the official residence of the Bishop of Buffalo. There is a little bit more work to be done to make it ready for that, since most of this floor will be for events.

So we're happy to have you. And I thank you very much.

I want to begin by thanking the many good people — clergy, laity, and religious within our diocese who have in the face of tragedy, anguish and confusion, remained steadfastly focused on Jesus and our ministry:

On caring for those in need, on celebrating the word of God and the sacraments and on treating the most vulnerable among us with true compassion and dignity. Even with so much goodness throughout our diocese, many are questioning the leadership of our church.

Whether we have lost sight of our values, whether we are adequately equipped to meet the heart-wrenching, persistent challenge of clergy sexual abuse — let me say that I hear your concerns, I understand them, I share them.

These past few weeks and months, Catholics have been confronted with unfathomable details of abuse — some decades old, some more recent.

Collectively, we have confronted the reality that the sinful actions of some priests have stretched further, deeper and longer than we could have expected.

With the benefit of hindsight, other, more recent allegations, which at the time, may have seemed hazy or difficult to substantiate, warranted more firm, more swift action.

Bishop Malone says he is not resigning, will start a task force to examine sex abuse of adults

Let me be clear: My handling of recent claims from some of our parishioners concerning sexual misconduct with adults unquestionably has fallen short of the standard to which you hold us, and to which we hold ourselves. We can do better, we will do better.

Since 2002, the charter for the protection of children and young people has been our guiding mandate. Our focus then has been on our children and teens. Those of us in church leadership have worked diligently to apply its protocols to our handling of abuse allegations.

In many ways, I have sought to make the charter my personal charge, to enforce this promise in a manner that honors survivors and protects those we serve.

However, reflecting on my handing of recent allegations of sexual misconduct with adults, I fear that in seeking to uphold the charter to the letter — and remember the charter is for young people — I may have lost sight of the charter’s spirit, which applies to people of all ages.

All of God’s children deserve the same protection from sexual harassment or contact, including adults.

Moreover, all of our church ministers must be the embodiment of the church's values. Illegal, harassing or unsettling behavior of any kind from those in ministry has a reverberating impact on our whole community, regardless of whether the behavior may be considered criminal.

In recent days, some within our Catholic community have urged me to resign.

I have prayed about this very question deeply, and I have sought guidance from colleagues, friends, brothers and sisters in ministry, and I am grateful for the support of so many.

And I stand before you today recommitted to my calling to serve as Bishop of Buffalo.

The shepherd does not desert the flock at a difficult time.

I, as many others, have learned, and will continue to learn from this difficult time, and I have drawn from these challenges the strength, the energy, the focus, to take the actions necessary to ensure, to the best of our ability, that our work is guided not just by precedent and policy but by a shared sense of good by our moral compass.

But now, now is the time for action.

Words alone do not suffice. Today, I promise you action.

I make a few promises to you today.

I am establishing a task force to examine the diocese’s procedures for handling claims of inappropriate conduct with adults and to recommend methods for honoring all victims in a manner consistent with our protection of children.

This task force will be comprised of laity, clergy and religious, and I will invite an elected official or two, and others.

Our intention is to bring a range of expertise and perspective to the task force’s work.

I am also establishing a new office for professional responsibility whose mission will be enforcement of our diocesan code of ethics.

While we continue to work through the decades-old abuses, we will do better in addressing our current decisions pertaining to clerics who violate sacred trusts.

I also pledge that our diocese will cooperate with any investigation initiated by the New York State Attorney General or District Attorney.

Most importantly, to the victims of clerical abuse of all ages, children and adults, I am profoundly sorry for the pain this has caused you. While nothing I can say to you could heal the hurt of this tragic breach of trust, as bishop of this diocese I do extend my most heartfelt apologies.

I want you to know that we will do all we can to restore your faith, to help you heal and to help you begin to move forward.

Please join me in praying first for victims of abuse everywhere.

And please find it in your heart, if you can, to pray also for me, and for all those who are trying to overcome the darkness of this sin, and bring back the true light of what the church should be for everyone.

And if I may, I will conclude with a prayer for healing for victims of abuse that we use throughout the country. It comes from the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops.

Holy Spirit, comforter of hearts, heal your people's wounds and transform brokenness into wholeness. Grant us the courage and the wisdom, the humility and grace, to act with justice. Breathe wisdom into our prayers and labors. Grant that all harmed by abuse may find peace in justice.

And we ask this through Christ, our Lord.


As you know, today is the day I usually do Q and A, but not today. Today is a day simply for this statement. At other times of course in the future, I’ll be available to entertain those.

Thank you for coming on a warm, summer afternoon. Thank you all.

Story topics:

There are no comments - be the first to comment