Supervisor Nathan McMurray, the lone Democrat on the Grand Island Town Board, said he "campaigned hard" to fill two open board seats with Democrats.
But Republicans Peter J. Marston Jr., the chairman of the Planning Board and owner of Marston Power Equipment, and Jennifer Baney, a former Williamsville elementary teacher, easily took the two spots, which were left open when the current Republicans on the board, Raymond Billica and Christopher Aronica, declined to run. Marston with 4,150 votes and Baney with 3,541 beat out Cynthia R. Montana, McMurray's former clerk, who had 2,679 votes and Celia N. Spacone with 2,568, according to unofficial Erie County Board of Election totals.
Recently appointed Republican Deputy Highway Superintendent Richard W. Crawford Jr. also edged out Democratic challenger Daniel C. Drexilius, 3,392 votes to 3,291, according to unofficial results.
McMurray, who was narrowly elected by just two votes two years ago, said the loss on Tuesday was crushing.
"It's partially about me as a supervisor, but I will continue to be me," said McMurray, who admits he is outspoken and strong willed.
"Obviously, I need to be more careful and empathetic as a human being - you always need to be a better person. But if you think I'm going to change my core beliefs or values because of one election - no way," McMurray said.
Baney said a pillar of her campaign was promoting civility on the board, which she said really resonated with the voters she spoke to.
"We are a close-knit community and people are arguing with their neighbors about Grand Island politics," said Baney. "There's a certain decorum, a certain way you should act, even if you don't agree."
McMurray has come under fire for his support of the removal of the West River Parkway to make way for a bike path and walking trail along the Niagara River, but he points to that and other state investments, including the planned Welcome Center and cashless tolling with unconcealed pride.
Marston said the state's plan to close the parkway was shortsighted, but added, "The state has made its decision and the town has to work with them to get the best park they can for the residents of Grand Island."
"I'm not against development, but I'm a huge fan of being smart about it," said Marston, who said developers are eyeing the huge tracts of open land on Grand Island. "We can't sell ourselves out. We have to look down the road."
Has McMurray lost his mandate from the people?
"No. My mandate lasts for four years from the day I was elected.," he said "You can run to stay or run to get things done. It's always been my goal to get things done. If you are popular and well-liked you are one politician. If you want to achieve change, you have to hope that change will be enough to get you reelected."
Marston and Baney will join current board members Michael Madigan, a Republican and a frequent opponent to McMurray, and Beverly Kinney, an Independent who ran as an endorsed Democrat.