By Jill Terreri
An effort to designate the Trico Complex a local landmark failed in the Common Council today in a 4-4 vote.
Voting against the measure was Ellicott Council Member Darius Pridgen, whose district includes the building, and Council President Richard Fontana, Majority Leader Demone Smith and Council Member Chris Scanlon.
Voting in favor of landmark status for Trico were Council Members David Franczyk, Joseph Golombek, David Rivera and Michael LoCurto.
Council Member Bonnie Russell did not attend Tuesday's meeting.
The Council requires five votes to approve any measure. The matter will not come up for another vote unless another landmark application is made.
Pridgen said his vote was not based on the desires of the Buffalo Niagara Medical Campus, which owns development rights to the property and was against the landmark designation. But Pridgen said the campus should work with the preservation community to find a re-use of the building and should move swiftly to develop the property, though he believes some of the structure is too far gone to rehabilitate it.
Council members who voted in favor of the designation said the city's own preservation law provides for landmark status for buildings that meet one out of nine criteria, and that the Trico building meets seven.
Public comment is generally not permitted at Council meetings, and those in favor and against landmark status weighed in during two previous Council committee meetings.