Share this article

print logo

Earnings reports fail to tell the whole story

NEW YORK – Procter & Gamble had been on a tear.

The company’s stock had climbed 22 percent since the start of the year as the maker of Tide detergent and Crest toothpaste turned in better profits for two quarters in a row. Last Thursday, P&G reported even higher earnings. And its stock immediately dropped 6 percent.

What happened? Like so many other big companies reporting results recently, P&G hit its target for earnings but missed on revenue. Nearly halfway through the first-quarter earnings season, corporate America is still reporting solid profits, with seven of every ten big companies hurdling over Wall Street’s expectations. Sales, however, are another story.

Nearly the same proportion of big companies – six out of ten – have fallen short of revenue targets, according to S&P Capital IQ. The tally so far looks grim: Revenue has shrunk 2.4 percent compared with last year.

“The norm is becoming, beat your earnings, but miss on revenue,” says Scott Freeze, president of Street One Financial.

Two problems persist: Europe’s ongoing recession and slower economic growth in China. Because nearly half of revenue for Standard & Poor’s 500 companies comes from abroad, it would seem logical to think the problem is just overseas. But many companies with a U.S. focus have also reported disappointing revenue.

Freeze says that revenue presents a more accurate picture of corporate America’s health.

“You can play with the earnings numbers and have them skewed,” he says. “But you can’t mess with the revenue numbers – they are what they are. If people are not coming in droves to buy your products, your revenue’s going to miss even if your earnings beat.”

Aside from Apple’s falling profit and some other high-profile flops, the headline numbers for first-quarter earnings appear solid. So far, 271 companies in the S&P 500 have said earnings are up 5 percent over the year before. And 189 of them have cleared Wall Street’s estimates.

Investors say that’s no surprise. They believe companies set the bar so low that it’s easy to jump over it. The 3.6 percent earnings growth analysts expect to see after all the results are tallied works out to $26.36. That’s just $1 more than the same period last year.

As one company after another turned in weak revenue results last week, analysts, investors and economists started raising concerns about the prospect for future profits.

Some of the biggest names in corporate America have disappointed, including Google, JPMorgan Chase and IBM, which posted its first drop in revenue in three years. In the past week, AT&T, Xerox and Safeway joined their ranks.

Of the 22 corporate giants in the Dow Jones industrial average that have reported results, 15 have missed their revenue targets, according to the data provider FactSet.

If the trend continues, experts see a number of consequences:

• Earnings estimates for the coming months will have to come down. Revenues drive profits. And if revenues start to sag, it’s going to be difficult for companies in the S&P 500 to have average earnings growth of 8 percent for the rest of the year, which is what analysts currently expect.

• To maintain their profit margins, companies will look for ways to trim expenses even more. That often means cutting jobs or scaling back spending. Earlier this month, for instance, Caterpillar announced plans to lay off workers in Milwaukee; Decatur, Ill.; and Brussels. The reason? Sales of Caterpillar’s large trucks and bulldozers had slumped.

The problem is that cost-cutting has its limits. U.S. companies already run more efficiently than they once did.

Jeffrey Kleintop, the chief market strategist at LPL Financial, is skeptical that companies will be able to shed enough expenses to hit their earnings targets.

“When there’s no more fat to cut,” he says, “you start to cut muscle, and then you’re cutting bone.”

• If either earnings estimates come down or layoffs pick up, it could easily upend the stock market’s four-year surge.

To be sure, many of the companies missing their revenue targets are grappling with their own unique problems, says John Butters, senior earnings analyst at FactSet. AT&T reported that fewer people signed up for phone plans. Boeing delivered just one 787 before the planes were grounded in January because of overheating batteries.

But the recurring theme is weak demand, says Tom Porcelli, chief U.S. economist at RBC Capital Markets. Businesses and individuals just aren’t spending enough to push sales up quarter after quarter.

“The economic backdrop remains sluggish,” he says. “It’s really as simple as that.”