Share this article

print logo

This Day in Buffalo Sports History, June 19, 1999: 'No goal'

Do the words "no goal" mean anything to you? Has it really been this long? Sigh.

The Sabres were trailing Dallas, three games to two, in the Stanley Cup finals. The teams were playing Game Six, which lasted until the third overtime, in Marine Midland Arena.

Then Brett Hull of the Stars came up with the puck around the Buffalo crease. With his foot in the crease, he put the puck past goalie Dominik Hasek for a Stanley Cup-winning goal. Or was it? The Sabres argued that the goal should be waved off – as many such goals were in NHL games that season.

No one is completely sure just how much of a look NHL officials gave to the play. The goal counted at 14:51 of the third overtime.

"Somebody should have called from upstairs and said, 'This is not a goal.' All I wanted was a review," Sabres coach Lindy Ruff said. "I wanted [NHL Commissioner Gary] Bettman to answer the question of why this wasn't reviewed. He turned his back on me. It was almost as if he knew this goal was tainted."

In a television interview, referee in chief Bryan Lewis downplayed the controversy, claiming Hull had continuous possession of the puck. However, when the NHL later released a memo about the "skate in the crease" rule, it seemed to indicate that the play didn't strictly follow any of the guidelines but that a reasonable reading of the rule would indicate the goal should not have counted.

As if it mattered once the Stanley Cup had been presented. And the play will anger Sabres fans forever.

There are no comments - be the first to comment