Share this article

print logo

Wall Street boosts city's credit rating

A leading Wall Street agency delivered a holiday message to Buffalo, boosting the city's credit rating to its highest level since 1999.

Standard & Poor's cites Buffalo's improving finances, good fiscal management and the continued oversight of a state control board in its decision to raise the rating a notch, to BBB stable. Until now, S&P assigned the lowest investment grade to Buffalo's general-obligation bonds.

City Comptroller Andrew A. SanFilippo hailed the development as "great news," adding he is confident the upgrade will result in lower long-term borrowing costs.

"You have Wall Street rating analysts recognizing the financial progress the city has made," said SanFilippo, who released a report Tuesday that S&P issued Thursday.

The BBB credit rating assigned by Standard & Poor's isn't exactly a glowing endorsement of Buffalo's finances. The rating basically means that a municipality has an adequate ability to meet obligations but is vulnerable to adverse economic conditions.

"It's significant that we're getting out of the lowest investment-grade category," SanFilippo said. "It shows the marketplace that we're not as much of a credit risk, and bondholders will look upon city bonds in a more favorable light."

SanFilippo traveled to New York City earlier this month and met with analysts to make a case for a credit-rating upgrade. He said S&P's action should help improve Buffalo's image among investors.

"We certainly can't be seen as a city that's on the brink of fiscal collapse," he said.

Still, S&P analysts warn that Buffalo continues to face long-term challenges.

"Buffalo's area economy is vulnerable in that the permanent population is declining and the tax base is stagnant," the S&P report states.

Analysts also cite projected city budget gaps that grow to $63 million by 2010.

"Additional challenges facing the city include hiring and retaining a well-qualified city work force and the resolution of outstanding [union] contracts," the analysts wrote.

But on a positive note, S&P said the city continues to increase the size of its fiscal cushion known as a general fund balance. S&P says the city closed the 2005-06 fiscal year with an $18.6 million operating surplus.

"Additional stability is provided by the continued control presence of [the Buffalo Fiscal Stability Authority] and its statutory powers to freeze hiring and wages," the report says.

If and when the control board becomes an advisory-only panel, analysts stressed, it will be imperative that city officials "diligently work" to craft balanced budgets.

Buffalo's control board was reviewing the S&P analysis and would likely have a response today, an aide to Executive Director Dorothy A. Johnson said Tuesday.

In August, another major Wall Street credit-rating agency said Buffalo's finances are improving. Moody's Investors Service removed its negative outlook on city bonds, replacing it with a positive outlook.

SanFilippo said he is cautiously optimistic that Moody's will eventually boost Buffalo's credit rating.

"While outlooks are important," he said, "the actual rating is most crucial."


There are no comments - be the first to comment