Share this article

print logo

10 Questions: Is Marcell Dareus the best DT in the division?

If only there was video footage of Buffalo Bills general manager Doug Whaley and Marcell Dareus the moment Ndamukong Suh’s $114 million contract went viral. One had to be thrilled, the other not so much.

The bulldozing defensive tackle Dareus enters the final year of his rookie contract and the timing couldn’t be more perfect for him.

Dareus is fresh off a career season, allowing him to use Suh’s historic number at the negotiating table. Whaley said in March that re-signing Dareus long term is “priority No. 1," but no deal is done yet.

So considering they’re both in the AFC East, who would you rather take? A compelling case can be made for both Dareus and Suh.

One NFL personnel executive sees Dareus on the level of Suh, Tampa Bay’s Gerald McCoy and the best in the game.

“Yeah, he’s probably as good as those guys,” the executive said. “You hear more about Suh. Suh probably has a little bit better of a pass rush, down in and down out, but it’s D-tackle. You can find film of Suh where he’s not going all out, either. Marcell’s a big dude who can do everything.”

Suh has the name recognition — albeit with a stomp here and a kick to the groin there — with his menacing mean streak and ability to change a game at any moment. He led the attitude adjustment in Detroit. The Lions were 2-30 the two seasons before taking him second overall in the 2010 draft and then went 6-10, 10-6, 4-12, 7-9 and 11-5 in his five seasons. Suh has averaged 47.6 tackles and 7.2 sacks per season.

In 2015, the Lions had the best run defense in the NFL… and it wasn’t even close. With Suh as the anchor, Detroit surrendered only 69.3 rushing yards per game and a ridiculously low 3.2 yards per carry — the lowest average in the NFL since 2007.

Suh possesses the most dangerous first step at the position and can embarrass linemen 1 on 1 with a club move or a bench press. So Miami rewarded him with a six-year, $114 million contract that includes $59.955 million guaranteed.

Expect speed rushers Cameron Wake and Olivier Vernon to benefit greatly.

Can Buffalo afford another $100 million dollar player on its defensive line? Mario Williams has a cap number of $19.4 million this season and the Bills may need to restructure his deal to free up cap room for Dareus. The former No. 1 overall pick is 30 years old.

As for Dareus, he has a strong case to make. His sack total has increased from 5.5 (twice) to 7.5. to 10 last season. Demanding double-teams at a nimble 331 pounds, he has helped free up both Williams and Jerry Hughes. Further, he might be the No. 1 reason the Bills’ run defense has finished 11th and fifth the last two years. Wider than Suh, with a motor that doesn't flicker as much, he'll control a gap with more regularity.

Dareus may play with better hands than Suh, leveraging, shucking and throwing linemen with regularity after the snap last season.

Rewind his sack in a 17-16 win over Minnesota last year in which the Vikings tried to double-team him with their left guard and left tackle. First, Dareus shoved away Charles Johnson off the snap, as Johnson lost his balance and faded away. Then, Dareus ripped around 6-foot-7 Matt Kalil with ease to take down quarterback Teddy Bridgewater.

At 25 years old, Dareus probably has more years in his prime left than the 28-year-old Suh.

Suh got paid. McCoy got a six-year, $95 million deal himself. Now, Whaley and the Bills are crunching the numbers to find room for Dareus. One conversation surely being had between the two sides is how Dareus compares with Suh. The numbers will probably be similar.

“We’ll wait and see what the Bills do,” Dareus said earlier in the off-season.

“It weighs on me heavily. Heavily. I’ve got to go out there and really perform and do what I have to do, which I always do — really have fun with it. Whatever the outcome is, is the outcome. However they want to play it is how they play it. I’m excited. I’m excited for the upcoming year.”

Previous 10 Questions posts...

Can Preston Brown handle Rex Ryan's defense?

Will the Bills' guard play turn around?

Can Sammy Watkins become a star in Year 2?

Story topics:

There are no comments - be the first to comment