Share this article

print logo

Two studies link common pesticide to decline in bees; Producer defends chemical as activists ask EPA to ban it

A common class of pesticide is causing problems for honeybees and bumblebees, important species that are already in trouble, two studies suggest.

But the findings don't explain all the reasons behind a long-running bee decline, and experts found one of the studies less than convincing.

The new research suggests the chemicals used in the pesticide -- designed to attack the central nervous system of insects -- reduces the weight and number of queens in bumblebee hives. These pesticides also cause honeybees to become disoriented and fail to return to their hives, the researchers concluded.

The two studies were published online Thursday in the journal Science.

Just last week, activists filed a petition with more than a million signatures asking the government to ban the class of pesticides called neonicotinoids. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency said it is re-evaluating the chemicals and is seeking scientific help.

For more than a decade, pollinators of all types have been in decline, mostly because of habitat loss and, perhaps, pesticide use. In the past five years, a mysterious honeybee problem known as colony collapse disorder has further reduced hives. But over the last couple of years, that problem has been observed a bit less, said Jeff Pettis, lead bee researcher at the U.S. Department of Agriculture's lab in Beltsville, Md.

Other studies have found problems with the pesticide class singled out in the research. These "strengthen the case for more thorough reassessing," said University of Illinois entomology professor May Berenbaum, who wasn't involved in the new studies. "But this is not a slam-dunk indictment that could compel a ban. It's complicated."

In the honeybee study, French scientists glued tiny radio transmitters to the bees managed for orchard pollination. The bees were tracked when they came and left the hive. Those that were dosed with neonicotinoids were two to three times more likely not to return.

"Where'd they go? We have no clue about that, actually," said study author Mickael Henry, a bee ecologist for the French national agriculture institute. His study said the pesticide likely contributes to colony collapse.

In the bumblebee study, British researchers dosed bees with the pesticide and moved their hives out into the field. After six weeks, they found the pesticide-treated hives were 10 percent lighter than those that weren't treated. And, more important, the hives that had pesticides lost about 85 percent of their queens.

"Queen production is, in some sense, the be-all and end-all," said study author David Goulson of the University of Stirling in Scotland.

Bayer Crop Sciences, which is the leading producer of neonicotinoids, says it is used on 90 percent of the corn grown in the United States and is safe. Bayer eco-toxicologist David Fischer said the honeybee study used unrealistically high doses of the chemicals, amounts that would not be used on crops bees normally pollinate.

Berenbaum, Pettis and a third outside scientist said the bumblebee study was more convincing than the honeybee research because it used lower doses and didn't make as many assumptions.

Bayer's Fischer said bumblebees may be more sensitive to the pesticide, an issue worth further study. But he said his company is one of the biggest growers of canola in Canada, where it uses the pesticide. The honeybees that pollinate Bayer's fields are "some of the healthiest bees in Canada," he said.

But environmental activists and some beekeepers are convinced the pesticide is a problem.

"The simple fact is, we know enough to take decisive action on this class of pesticides, which covers well over 143 million acres of U.S. countryside," said Heather Pilatic, co-director of Pesticide Action Network North America.

The EPA, in a prepared statement, said the decline in bee health is due to "complex interactions" that involve inadequate food sources, diseases caused by parasites and viruses, habitat loss and bee management practices, as well as pesticides.

Bees are needed to pollinate fruit, vegetables and nuts. Without them, experts say, our diets would be bland. Honeybees, which aren't native to America, are managed by professional beekeepers, carted from farm to orchard and raised to produce honey. Bumblebees, native to this country, are wild pollinators.

Without bees, Berenbaum said, "we'd be a scurvy-ridden society."

There are no comments - be the first to comment